Specialist vs. generalist
File Logic vs. Paxton AI
Paxton is a great general-purpose legal assistant. File Logic is built around the record-heavy workflow plaintiff firms actually run.
Where Paxton AI stands today.
Paxton AI is a general-purpose legal assistant covering research, drafting, and document analysis, with a medical chronologies feature.
Paxton AI is a credible all-in-one legal assistant — research, drafting, document analysis, plus a medical chronologies feature. If your firm wants one AI tool for everything from contracts to research, Paxton is a reasonable bet. File Logic is the opposite shape: a focused, depth-first tool for the medical-record-to-work-product workflow that drives SSD, VA, PI, and Workers' Comp cases.
File Logic vs. Paxton AI, attribute by attribute.
No checkmark spam. Real product attributes — pricing posture, onboarding, citations, scan handling, practice-area depth — so you can make an honest decision.
- Primary focusMedical record analysis for plaintiff firmsGeneral legal assistant
- Handles scanned, handwritten, faxed recordsHandles scans, handwriting, faxed PDFsYes, varies by document quality
- Cited medical chronologiesCited medical chronologies in minutesAvailable as a feature
- Practice areas with tailored outputSSD, VA, PI, Workers' CompGeneral-purpose templates
- Citations on every answerPage-level citation on every answerCitations included
- Free trial14-day free trial, no cardFree tier available
- Reusable firm-specific templatesReusable report and brief templatesYes
- HIPAA-ready, BAA availableHIPAA-ready, BAA availableSecurity-focused
- Best forRecord-heavy plaintiff workGeneralist legal practice
Comparison reflects public product information at time of writing. Competitor product capabilities may have changed; if anything is out of date, let us know.
Where File Logic wins.
Built for messy records
Scans, handwriting, faxes — the records you actually get.
Plaintiff firms know the truth: medical records arrive as scanned PDFs, hand-written notes, faxed pages, and the occasional photo of a chart. General legal AI tools are trained on clean text. File Logic is built for the records as they actually show up in your office.
- Handles scanned hospital records, handwriting, and poor-quality PDFs
- Everything becomes searchable and reviewable
- No preprocessing or OCR step required from your team
Practice-area depth
Templates and prompts shaped to the case type.
SSD wants RFC limitations and treating-source opinions surfaced. VA wants nexus evidence connected across the C-file. PI wants accident-related treatment, gaps, and costs. A general legal assistant gives you one template; File Logic gives you the right output for the case you are actually working.
- Dedicated workflows for SSD, VA, PI, and Workers' Comp
- Save reusable report and brief templates per practice area
- Tailored to the evidence each case type actually turns on
Single source of truth
Citations to your file. Not external research.
Paxton mixes document analysis with legal research and external sources. File Logic deliberately does not. The AI works only with the records you upload and your firm's knowledge base — never other clients, never external sources — so the chronology a partner reviews is grounded entirely in the case file.
- AI works only with uploaded documents and your firm's knowledge
- No external research mixed into chronology output
- Per-organization isolation; nothing crosses between cases
When Paxton AI may be the better pick.
If your firm wants a single AI tool that covers contextual legal research, contract review, and case research alongside document analysis, Paxton's generalist breadth is genuinely useful. File Logic is purpose-built for the medical-record workflow — depth over breadth.
- You want one tool covering legal research and contract review
- Medical records are a small part of your practice mix
- You value breadth across legal tasks over plaintiff-specific depth
Common questions about switching from Paxton AI.
See File Logic on your own records.
No credit card. No sales call required to evaluate.